Home › Market insights › Sugar

How to Verify a Brazilian ICUMSA 45 Sugar Offer: A Buyer’s Checklist for November 2026

By Abe Dinkel, Commodities Trader, Dossix International Trade Inc · November 4, 2026 · 6 min read

Why this matters right now

Sugar has fallen fast. On November 3, December London #5 white sugar settled at US$500.20 per tonne, down US$9.20 on the day, and March New York #11 raw sugar at 18.33 c/lb, down 0.73 c (Czarnikow, November 3, 2026). The week before, #11 had already dropped below 20 c/lb while speculators cut their net long position by 40,700 lots to 180,700 lots (Czarnikow, November 2, 2026).

A falling market brings out two kinds of offers: real sellers repricing, and "too good to be true" offers that use the volatility as cover. A Brazilian trading firm describes one importer who was offered ICUMSA 45 "at a price 30% below market", paid, and lost more than $200,000 when no cargo arrived (Mello Commodity). The same article lists the usual tactics: forged documents carrying the names of real Brazilian companies, requests for upfront commissions, and "representatives" on WhatsApp who vanish after payment. Here is how we would test any ICUMSA 45 offer before signing anything.

Check 1: Does the price make sense against the exchange?

ICE's London White Sugar contract is the global benchmark for physical white sugar. It is delivered FOB and stowed in the vessel's hold at a port in an approved origin country, and Brazil is on the list (ICE Futures Europe). That makes it the reference for ICUMSA 45. A CIF offer is the FOB value plus ocean freight and insurance, so it should come in above the London price, not below it.

With December whites at US$500.20/t on November 3, a "CIF" ICUMSA 45 offer below that level is quoting less than the exchange before a single dollar of freight. A real exporter would simply sell to the market instead. Ask the seller to explain the price as the exchange price plus or minus a premium, plus freight. A real seller can do that in one line.

Check 2: Is the specification complete and testable?

"ICUMSA 45" on its own is a colour number, not a full specification. The ICE white sugar contract, for example, requires a minimum polarisation of 99.8°, moisture of no more than 0.06%, and colour of no more than 45 ICUMSA units at the time of loading (ICE Futures Europe). Colour is measured by a defined laboratory method: ICUMSA's "White Sugar Solution Colour" method, formerly GS2/3-10 and now GS2-10 (ICUMSA). Polarisation and colour together show how pure the sugar is (Czarnikow).

A serious offer states each parameter, the crop year, the packing, the loading port and who inspects at loading, and it ties price adjustments to that inspection. If an offer lists only "ICUMSA 45, 50 kg bags" and a price, that tells you nothing you can enforce.

Check 3: Does the seller exist in Brazil's registers?

Every Brazilian company has a CNPJ. Anyone can print the company's registration status certificate (Comprovante de Inscrição e de Situação Cadastral) from the Receita Federal website at no cost (Receita Federal). Check four things: the registration is active, the legal name matches the contract and the bank account exactly, the registered activity fits sugar trading or production, and the address is real.

Then check that the company is cleared to export. Brazilian firms need a foreign-trade clearance, commonly called RADAR, to operate in foreign trade. The public check has moved. The Receita page states that from August 31, 2026 the lookup is done through the Portal Único Siscomex (Cadastro de Intervenientes › Habilitação › Consultar Habilitação), and that the old page would be switched off on September 30, 2026 (Receita Federal; Portal Único Siscomex). If a "mill mandate" cannot give you a CNPJ that passes both checks, stop there.

Check 4: Are the documents real?

Sample SGS reports, "proof of product" and bills of lading are the most commonly forged papers in this trade. SGS runs a free service to confirm whether an SGS-branded certificate or report is genuine: you submit the PDF through its verification form (SGS). ICC's Commercial Crime Services warns that "fake or false trade and transport documents feature in the majority of modern maritime frauds". Its information department authenticates bills of lading and other transport documents for members and can report on a named vessel's history (ICC Commercial Crime Services). Never rely on a document because it looks official. Check it with the party that supposedly issued it.

Check 5: Who is actually selling?

Many "offers" pass through four or five intermediaries before they reach a buyer. Each one adds commission, and none of them can guarantee the cargo. Ask plainly who holds the title to the sugar at loading and whose name will be on the commercial invoice. If the answer keeps changing, or you cannot reach the seller's own staff and only "the mandate" responds, treat that as a warning in itself.

Check 6: Are the payment terms safe for both sides?

Requests for upfront commissions or deposits before any shipment are a classic scam pattern (Mello Commodity). In our view, the safe structure for a new relationship is a signed sales contract (SPA), then a documentary letter of credit (DLC) from the buyer's bank. The seller is paid against presentation of compliant shipping documents, including the independent loading inspection certificate. Bank instruments such as an SBLC belong after the contract is signed, never as a "proof of funds" sent to strangers.